china_shop: A close-up of the Envoy's mouth and chin, with just the bottom edge of his mask in frame. (Guardian - Envoy)
The Gauche in the Machine ([personal profile] china_shop) wrote in [community profile] sid_guardian2024-12-14 01:30 pm
Entry tags:

Guardian readalong: chapters 11 & 12

Hello! Welcome back (or just welcome!) to our readalong of Guardian! Whatever translation you're reading, whatever language you're reading it in, please join in our discussion!

Previous read-along posts, all still open for comments:


This week's chapters are 11 and 12 of the official translation, starting with Zhao Yunlan & co returning to the SID, and taking us up to the end of the Reincarnation Dial arc.

Chapter 11: When they return to the SID, Zhao Yunlan explains Xiao Guo's working conditions and benefits; the Soul-Executing Emissary pays a visit; Zhao Yunlan and Lin Jing interrogate Li Qian while the Emissary and Xiao Guo look on.
Chapter 12: Li Qian says the Reincarnation Dial turned her grandmother into a monster, and Xiao Guo tells her the truth; the Soul-Executing Emissary leaves to find the Dial; Zhao Yunlan arrives in time to hear a monster deliver a message from his master to the Emissary; the Dial is missing.

Excerpts
1) Guo Changcheng sets the lowest bar imaginable for himself, 2) Our first impression of the Soul-Executing Emissary, 3) A monster delivers a message

1) Guo Changcheng sets the lowest bar imaginable for himself
Compared to an evening of being chased by the Hunger Ghost, scurrying and clambering all over the place, lao-Wu’s papier-mâché face seemed downright kind. Guo Changcheng smiled weakly and kept his real feelings to himself. “I-It was great…”

Lao-Wu laughed, bright and clear. “It’s okay if you’re not used to it at first. Work hard and learn. You’re alive! You have potential!”

For the first time, Guo Changcheng realized that even he had an advantage in this workforce: he was alive.


2) Our first impression of the Soul-Executing Emissary
The guest’s slim body was entirely wrapped in a black robe that hid even his hands and feet, and his face was concealed by a veil of black mist. Nothing else could be discerned through all the inky blackness. He first stopped at the door, then bowed to Zhao Yunlan from a distance, hands together. His long sleeves swept the tops of his feet as he spoke. “My apologies for the disturbance.”

Zhao Yunlan held up a yellow paper talisman, lit it, and let the ashes fall into a cup of hot tea. The ashes dissolved in an instant, taking all the heat from the cup with them. In the same moment, a steaming cup appeared in the black-robed man’s hands.

[...]

As he passed by, Guo Changcheng caught a scent. It wasn’t the rotting smell they’d encountered at the hospital; it wasn’t foul at all. It was a very light fragrance that reminded Guo Changcheng of midwinter at the foot of the Daxing’anling Mountains far to the north. It was the scent that accompanies the first breath when you push open the door and walk out into the morning after a whole night of snow. It was the scent of endless, eternally unmelting snow: pure and impossibly cold, tinged with the last fragrance of dying blossoms. The scent carried far into the distance, all the way to the end of the road of life.

The Soul-Executing Emissary spoke softly and eloquently, like a scholar in a period drama. Objectively, other than the eerie black mist concealing his face, he was unremarkable. But as Guo Changcheng came fully awake, he was filled with an unforgettable fear—a fear that was baseless and irrational but rooted in his very soul.


3) A monster delivers a message
The monster turned its neck stiffly under the blade and looked in Zhao Yunlan’s direction. It replied to the Emissary but didn’t answer his question. “My master asked me to convey a message. My lord, you have performed your duties meticulously for centuries, each day like the one before. You’ve avoided the person enshrined at the tip of your heart much as you’d avoid raging floods and savage beasts. To all appearances you are the epitome of self-control, but don’t you truly fear being unable to control yourself?”

The Emissary said nothing, but the coldness emanating from him grew heavier.

“My master has tremendous sympathy for your deep feelings, my lord, and went to the effort of having him brought before you. He wished to see if you are truly without desire, without—”

This time, the Emissary didn’t let the creature finish. His blade flashed, turning the wart-covered head into a fountain of blood.


Questions
What do you think of the working conditions at the SID? Did reading about Xiao Guo's merits change your opinion of him? Can Zhao Yunlan make good tea, or is the Emissary just being polite? What's your impression of the Emissary based on these chapters?

Poll #32362 Terminology
Open to: Registered Users, detailed results viewable to: All, participants: 10


Which do you prefer for the novel?

View Answers

Soul-Executing Emissary
1 (10.0%)

Ghost Slayer
5 (50.0%)

Soul-Slaying Envoy
1 (10.0%)

Zhanhunshi
3 (30.0%)

other
1 (10.0%)



You can see the schedule and sign up to host a post here.
autodach: Count von Count reading (Graf)

[personal profile] autodach 2024-12-14 01:24 pm (UTC)(link)
Zhao Yunlan held up a yellow paper talisman, lit it, and let the ashes fall into a cup of hot tea.

This is so cool! Love this way of making tea for Zhanhunshi. It immediately sets him apart from the living beings present, but also shows Zhao Yunlan making an effort to accommodate his other-ness.


What do you think of the working conditions at the SID?

They need a union to ensure worker safety and proper onboarding for new hires.


Can Zhao Yunlan make good tea, or is the Emissary just being polite?

Good question! I also wonder if he can taste the ashes, and if so, does that make the tea better or worse?


What's your impression of the Emissary based on these chapters?

A scary ghost with good manners. Love him❤
trobadora: (Black-Cloaked Envoy)

[personal profile] trobadora 2024-12-15 11:41 pm (UTC)(link)
And accommodating the other-ness without making too big a deal about it. It's very cool. :D

This, exactly! ♥ ♥ ♥
cathyw: Gromit pouring tea (Default)

[personal profile] cathyw 2024-12-16 12:22 am (UTC)(link)
hrum. the talisman was applied to the tea, and sends the tea across, but would you need another talisman to send the talisman across?

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2024-12-16 01:22 (UTC) - Expand
trobadora: (Zhao Yunlan - patience)

[personal profile] trobadora 2024-12-15 11:41 pm (UTC)(link)
It immediately sets him apart from the living beings present, but also shows Zhao Yunlan making an effort to accommodate his other-ness.

Yes! I really love that!
trobadora: (Black-Cloaked Envoy)

[personal profile] trobadora 2024-12-16 12:09 am (UTC)(link)
Honestly, I just wish it were "Black-Cloaked Envoy" and I didn't have to think about it. ;-p

LOL! That would be the most convenient, yeah. *g*

I find the Emissary's face being concealed behind a veil of mist super uncanny and disturbing.

Heh. I really like it myself, but it's meant to be uncanny, so your reaction is probably more fitting. I just really appreciate him being so entirely Other, with no hint of a human face to make it easier. And ZYL being entirely unbothered by it!

"Lord-Executing Emissary" -- this is incredibly nitpicky, but that hyphen made me laugh.

He could execute some lords, for a treat? *g*

But I'm sad Daqing sleeps through the whole thing, so we don't get to see his reaction to the Emissary.

Seriously!

The Emissary starts explaining his presence with "For a few reasons," but I think he only gave one: the Reincarnation Dial? Did I miss something?

If you missed it, I missed it too.

Spoilery: The Emissary explaining the seal in terms of hearsay ("Legend describes them...") is a deliberate misdirect, right? I don't understand why he chooses to conceal his first-hand knowledge. It's not like everyone doesn't know he's ancient.

Yeah, it has to be, though idk either why he's concealing it.

??? Is this a magic power? Are the ropes magic? What am I missing?

I was assuming ZYL had powers.

I love Lin Jing knowing how to work with Zhao Yunlan during the interrogation. It's harsh on Li Qian, but the seamless good cop-bad cop routine is pretty great.

Yeah, it's pretty well done! And it makes sense, now that ZYL has actually figured something out - before, I felt like he was being mean without reason, but this time, the reason is there, and I can appreciate the competence.

I didn't catch the stuff about the Bottle of Rebirth.

THANK YOU, I'm so glad it's not just me who lost the plot there!!!

Ooh, the monster's message: such a taunt. Isn't his "master" basically going, "You're so thirsty for [spoiler] -- can you even control yourself?" Hitting the Emissary right where it hurts, and the Emissary is have NONE of that.

But it hurts anyway! Yeah, our villain really knows where to aim.

The chill that Xiao Guo feels when the Emissary arrives -- does that mean the clouds of smoke on drama!Envoy's first arrival at the SID are actually condensation?

I always thought it was fog, not smoke!

Zhao Yunlan makes the Emissary tea, vs drama!ZYL saying, "Next time, come early, I'll treat you to some first-class tea."

Yes! Such a neat callback even though they couldn't have a scene like that in the drama because no ghosts also means no ghost tea. *g*

The Emissary called Zhao Yunlan "the Guardian", which seems much more formal than the Envoy's "Zhao-xiong" to me?

Yeah, agreed.

"The Guardian must not joke so carelessly." cf variations on "Don't joke about [your health/your family]" in the drama. :D :D :D

Indeed! :D :D :D

Yes!! I wish we'd got the Emissary's reaction, but I suppose that would have been a bit too revealing.

Yeah, but also, those lines gain so much when you can see SW reacting to them!

Oh, Li Qian's granny is Wang Yufen here, not Li Yufen -- I guess they made her a paternal grandmother for the drama?

No, she's her 奶奶 nǎinai, paternal grandmother, in both. (I just double-checked the Chinese version of the novel.) It's more unusual for her to be surnamed Li in the drama, since it means she and her husband must have had the same surname. (Which used to be considered taboo, once!)

Having drama!Li Qian conscious for her grandmother's intervention was so much kinder than having novel!Xiao Guo scold her for not knowing her grandmother loves her. /o\

Yeah, I didn't really like that part in the novel, tbh. Seriously, poor novel!Li Qian. She gets the short end of the stick every time.
Edited 2024-12-16 00:10 (UTC)

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2024-12-16 01:19 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2024-12-16 01:26 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] cathyw - 2024-12-16 14:27 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2024-12-16 17:51 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] circumference_pie - 2024-12-16 17:36 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2024-12-16 17:56 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] circumference_pie - 2024-12-16 18:21 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2024-12-16 18:23 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] cathyw - 2024-12-16 19:19 (UTC) - Expand
trobadora: (Black-Cloaked Envoy)

[personal profile] trobadora 2024-12-15 11:39 pm (UTC)(link)
For the first time, Guo Changcheng realized that even he had an advantage in this workforce: he was alive.

That is such a good line, LOL.

I love the ghost tea and how it combines with the Envoy's image, completely Other and mysterious. :D

And I'm just calling him the Envoy for now, because none of the translations of his title quite work for me, but "Envoy" is definitely better than "Emissary", and if I had to choose between the options in the poll, I'd go with Soul-Slaying Envoy.

Some more random observations/thoughts:
  • The SID has a cafeteria! How many people do they have?!

  • sprawling forward on the table like a dead dog is such a delightfully vivid description! :D

  • LOL, Lord-Executing Emissary is some typo! (In the Chinese version he just calls him by his title.)

  • This is such a completely different vibe from their first meeting in the drama, where ZYL is all passive-aggressive and borderline rude right until GCC puts his foot in it and needs to be "rescued". Here, we've got a cordial working relationship between ZYL and the Envoy, and SW even sits down with ZYL, and then again in the interrogation room - something the drama version of the Envoy never does. (The only time I can remember the Envoy sitting is in YOHE.) And GCC's main contribution here is in Li Qian's interrogation, where he confronts her with the truth about her grandma's spirit sacrificing herself for her, which I don't like nearly as much as I do his drama counterpart's bravery, speaking up when something seems wrong even though he's terrified.

  • Also, for all that it's the first time we see ZYL and the Envoy together, it's pretty much a non-event as far as personal dynamics between them go, which I found a bit disappointing.

  • Another thing I found a bit disappointing: The black cat was dead to the world, so he didn't count.

    Depriving us of Daqing's reaction to the Envoy, boo! (Deliberately hiding it? I don't remember anything, but it does seem awfully convenient ...)

  • He obviously came from the southern hemisphere, Guo Changcheng told himself. It's winter there right now. He shut his eyes, too afraid to keep looking at the Soul-Executing Emissary, and tried to comfort himself with the logic of Core Socialist Values: Have faith in science, freedom, democracy, harmony...

    Have genre awareness instead, Xiao-Guo! *g*

  • The whole conversation between ZYL and the Envoy about the Reincarnation Dial and the Hallows isn't in the current Chinese version; it goes straight to them going to the interrogation room. I do think it makes sense to seed some of the background mythology early ...

  • Li Qian's confession: truthful here, I assume, since it's the end of the arc. Very interesting that they decided to make it a false confession in the drama, and let it resonate with the drama's theme of things being other than they seem at first. (Also, poor novel!Li Qian, even so.)

  • "One day we will meet in the Netherworld. On that day, I will await you with justice."

    Ominous! I wonder what he means by it.

  • Having gotten rid of the gullible little intern, Lin Jing turned to Zhao Yunlan. "I didn't see the Emissary pass you anything. Li Qian touched the Hallowed Artifact from the Netherworld without permission, so she must suffer this hardship. The old woman was willing to take it for her, so she died for a reason. It's all just cause and effect, so what is there to be lenient about?"

    Very good questions all, I would like some answers myself ... At least Lin Jing asking is reassuring insofar as it should mean there is an answer, LOL, but it for sure left me feeling like I missed something. Can anyone explain?

  • To all appearances you are the epitome of self-control, but don't you truly fear being unable to control yourself?

    Ha, yeah, that sounds right about novel!SW's self-image - that's exactly the impression I got of him, though I couldn't exactly say from where. *g*

  • And one more bit of drama comparison: The black hole the Envoy steps into vs. the amethyst geode visual the drama made for his portals - yeah, definitely a good choice for what works better in a visual canon, whereas "black hole" is more evocative in written form.
Edited 2024-12-15 23:40 (UTC)
trobadora: (Black-Cloaked Envoy)

[personal profile] trobadora 2024-12-16 12:20 am (UTC)(link)
At the start of chapter 7, it says, "By daylight, the office looked far bleaker. The only person on duty in the criminal investigation unit was a female officer who might have been in her twenties." So maybe there are other units, too? But if so, what do they do? And is ZYL in charge of all of them?

Oh, great catch! Yeah, I'd assume ZYL was in charge of them all, but maybe only personally working with criminal investiation? Idk.

Oh really? Not even a "daren"?

Nope, just his title!

I'd say that the ep 14 post-reveal tea-drinking scene is Shen Wei as plain-clothes Envoy?

I wouldn't count it, since the boundary between identities isn't intact any more at that point, but yeah, that's probably the closest it comes!

So yeah, Li Qian's confession must be real. I wonder when Zhao Yunlan worked that out...

Yeah, good question! Some time after learning about the Reincarnation Dial from Zhu Hong, it must have been ...

[personal profile] circumference_pie 2024-12-16 06:43 am (UTC)(link)
> Having gotten rid of the gullible little intern, Lin Jing turned to Zhao Yunlan. "I didn't see the Emissary pass you anything. Li Qian touched the Hallowed Artifact from the Netherworld without permission, so she must suffer this hardship. The old woman was willing to take it for her, so she died for a reason. It's all just cause and effect, so what is there to be lenient about?"

> Very good questions all, I would like some answers myself ... At least Lin Jing asking is reassuring insofar as it should mean there is an answer, LOL, but it for sure left me feeling like I missed something. Can anyone explain?

I just got to this part and I’m confused too…I think EITHER Zhao Yunlan captured the old lady’s spirit in the Bottle of Rebirth of his own initiative because he felt sorry for Li Qian and her grandmother, was pre-emptively heading off GCC’s misery, or is just capricious; OR he’s lying wholesale to Guo Changcheng and what GCC saw in the bottle was just a trick.

Based on Lin Jing’s “what reason is there to be merciful?” though, I’m inclined to believe the former.

Also, Lin Jing also asks him, “why are you going through such lengths to make the intern feel better?” or something like that, and I think the answer may be related to the shining spiritual thing he sensed on GCC last chapter.

(no subject)

[personal profile] cathyw - 2024-12-16 14:35 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] circumference_pie - 2024-12-16 17:00 (UTC) - Expand
trobadora: (Shen Wei - don't know)

[personal profile] trobadora 2024-12-16 05:42 pm (UTC)(link)
So glad it's not just me being confused! Thanks for explaining what you've puzzled out, and I'll keep hoping for canon to clarify further. *g* But I agree that it sounds less like he's lying, though possibly the mercy is in sparing GCC the unpleasant truth? Idk ...

Also, Lin Jing also asks him, “why are you going through such lengths to make the intern feel better?” or something like that, and I think the answer may be related to the shining spiritual thing he sensed on GCC last chapter.

Oh, yeah, that's what I was assuming - that he's looking at GCC differently because he's realised there's something more to him, even if it doesn't yet add up for him.

(no subject)

[personal profile] circumference_pie - 2024-12-16 18:19 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2024-12-16 18:23 (UTC) - Expand
cathyw: Gromit pouring tea (Default)

[personal profile] cathyw 2024-12-16 01:32 pm (UTC)(link)
Also, for all that it's the first time we see ZYL and the Envoy together, it's pretty much a non-event as far as personal dynamics between them go, which I found a bit disappointing.

Not only did we get no Da Qing reaction or POV, we got no Envoy POV, only ZYL's POV of the Envoy. (rot13) guvaxvat nobhg vg, rirel ovg bs Fura Jrv'f ernpgvba gb Munb Lhayna xvaq bs arrqf gb or erpbagrkghnyvmrq jvgu gur xabjyrqtr gung ur vfa'g whfg ohzcvat vagb uvz sbe gur svefg gvzr va 10,000 lrnef, ohg gurl'ir orra zrrgvat erthyneyl sbe jbex ernfbaf sbe ng yrnfg frireny lrnef.

(as an aside, are we considering the thing I'm rot13ing about a spoiler? are there people here who haven't seen the drama and are new to the book?)
Edited 2024-12-16 13:33 (UTC)

(no subject)

[personal profile] circumference_pie - 2024-12-16 17:02 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2024-12-16 17:45 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] cathyw - 2024-12-16 19:27 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2024-12-16 19:34 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] cathyw - 2024-12-16 23:18 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2024-12-18 00:26 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] ride_4ever - 2024-12-18 01:23 (UTC) - Expand
cathyw: Gromit pouring tea (Default)

[personal profile] cathyw 2024-12-16 12:50 am (UTC)(link)
yikes, I am behind, I think I missed last week entirely. So I kind of breezed through this week's chapters...

"To all appearances you are the epitome of self-control, but don’t you truly fear being unable to control yourself?”

Yes, yes he does. And how he must have hated that ZYL was there to hear that.

The Envoy really did seem like what ZYL described: polite, courteous, perhaps a little old-fashioned... and also dispassionately standing in a pile of corpses he's just created to interrogate a little monster-ghost about where the Resurrection Dial has gotten off to... and also the one who will be meeting you with Justice when you reach the Netherworld. The thing is... you know what you did. I suspect for most people (and especially ghosts) being in his presence reminds you of every time you used the work printer for personal business and every rolling stop you've ever made in your car, or some spiritual equivalent thereof.
trobadora: (Black-Cloaked Envoy)

[personal profile] trobadora 2024-12-16 01:24 am (UTC)(link)
You can always come back to last week's post if you have the time/inclination! No worries and no rush. :)

And how he must have hated that ZYL was there to hear that.

Seriously!!!!!

I suspect for most people (and especially ghosts) being in his presence reminds you of every time you used the work printer for personal business and every rolling stop you've ever made in your car, or some spiritual equivalent thereof.

That is such a fantastic description, wow!

[personal profile] circumference_pie 2024-12-17 02:33 am (UTC)(link)
Most of what I wanted to say about this chapter has already been said, but I gotta re-emphasize:

GCC is such an empathetic and relatable character. I liked it a lot when he smiled back at lao-Wu. That’s growth.

Also, he was the only real “good cop” in that room.

I’m a bit confused by what happened with the teacup. Can the Emissary not hold physical objects?

The Emissary truly sounds just as Zhao Yunlan described him. I wonder why ZYL is not affected by The Fear. Is the Emissary deliberately suppressing it for him or is the Soul-Guarding Token helping?

I wonder if the Emissary is also distorting his voice?

I found Li Qian much less sympathetic in this than in the show.
trobadora: (Black-Cloaked Envoy)

[personal profile] trobadora 2024-12-18 12:30 am (UTC)(link)
Also, he was the only real “good cop” in that room.

100% truth.

I’m a bit confused by what happened with the teacup. Can the Emissary not hold physical objects?

I think Zhao Yunlan doesn't know he can?

The Emissary truly sounds just as Zhao Yunlan described him. I wonder why ZYL is not affected by The Fear. Is the Emissary deliberately suppressing it for him or is the Soul-Guarding Token helping?

I figured it's more that ZYL is willing to see beyond the surface, though I expect him being the Guardian does help. I don't think it's something others wouldn't be capable of, though! (Or at least I wouldn't like it if it were like that.)

I found Li Qian much less sympathetic in this than in the show.

I mean, drama!Li Qian didn't kill her granny, so, yeah. *g* But I still felt for novel!Li Qian a lot; she was clearly completely at the end of her rope with no support whatsoever.

(no subject)

[personal profile] amedia - 2025-01-12 03:43 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2025-01-12 22:06 (UTC) - Expand
ride_4ever: (Fraser - thinking cap)

[personal profile] ride_4ever 2024-12-18 01:25 am (UTC)(link)
I'm seeing all this convo about various names in English for Zhanhunshi, and clearly there's a lot of strong and varying opinions out there. Me, I never questioned the title "Soul-Executing Emissary".

I particularly like where Lao-Wu says to Guo Changcheng "You're alive! You have potential!" (I like that I can apply that to myself and those around me IRL.)
trobadora: (Black-Cloaked Envoy)

[personal profile] trobadora 2024-12-18 09:20 pm (UTC)(link)
Good to know that it works for new readers!

And yeah, that is such a good line. :D
amedia: Skinny young man looking worried, sitting in a chair with a blank wall next to him. Caption says Xiao Guo. (Guardian: Guo 1)

[personal profile] amedia 2025-01-12 03:47 am (UTC)(link)
I particularly like where Lao-Wu says to Guo Changcheng "You're alive! You have potential!" (I like that I can apply that to myself and those around me IRL.)

That's such a cool way to look at it! As I mentioned above regarding Li Qian, I wasn't sure what to expect from the novel (other than a vague impression of Chinese mythology and actual BL), but it's been a much richer experience than I expected.

(no subject)

[personal profile] trobadora - 2025-01-12 22:07 (UTC) - Expand